Changes for page SDMX 3.0 Standards. Section 5. Registry Specification: Logical Functionality

Last modified by Helena on 2025/09/10 11:19

From 21.13 to 21.12 From 31.1 to 30.2

From version 30.2

edited by Helena
on 2025/05/16 23:37

Change comment: There is no comment for this version

To version 21.13

edited by Helena
on 2025/05/15 14:30

Change comment: There is no comment for this version

Raw
Rendered

Summary

Page properties (2 modified, 0 added, 0 removed)
Objects (0 modified, 0 added, 1 removed)
- SUZ.Methodology.Code.MethodologyClass[0]

Details

Page properties

Tags

...	...	@@ -1,1 +1,0 @@
1		-Artefact\|Attribute\|Category scheme\|Code list\|Component\|Data set\|Data structure definition\|Dataflow\|Dimension\|Maintenance agency\|Measure\|Metadata repository\|Metadata set\|Metadata structure definition\|Metadataflow\|Notification\|Provision agreement\|Reference metadata\|SDMX Information Model\|SDMX Registry\|SDMX-JSON\|SDMX-ML\|Statistical data and metadata exchange\|Structural metadata

Content

@@ -2,8 +2,7 @@
  {{toc/}}
  {{/box}}
--(% class="wikigeneratedid" id="HRevisionHistory" %)
--**Revision History**
++= Revision History =
  (((
  (% style="width:838.294px" %)
@@ -14,69 +14,69 @@
  = 1 Introduction =
--The business vision for [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] envisages the promotion of a “data sharing” model to facilitate low-cost, high-quality [[statistical data and metadata exchange>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]]. Data sharing reduces the reporting burden of organisations by allowing them to publish data once and let their counterparties “pull” data and related metadata as required. The scenario is based on:
++The business vision for SDMX envisages the promotion of a “data sharing” model to facilitate low-cost, high-quality statistical data and metadata exchange. Data sharing reduces the reporting burden of organisations by allowing them to publish data once and let their counterparties “pull” data and related metadata as required. The scenario is based on:
--* the availability of an abstract information model capable of supporting time series and cross-sectional data, [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]], and [[reference metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Reference metadata.WebHome]] ([[SDMX-IM>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX Information Model.WebHome]])
--* standardised XML and JSON schemas for the [[SDMX-ML>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX-ML.WebHome]] and [[SDMX-JSON>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX-JSON.WebHome]] formats derived from the model (XSD, JSON)
++* the availability of an abstract information model capable of supporting time series and cross-sectional data, structural metadata, and reference metadata (SDMX-IM)
++* standardised XML and JSON schemas for the SDMX-ML and SDMX-JSON formats derived from the model (XSD, JSON)
  * the use of web-services technology (XML, JSON, Open API)
--Such an architecture needs to be well organised, and the [[SDMX Registry>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX Registry.WebHome]]/Repository (SDMXRR) is tasked with providing structure, organisation, and maintenance and query interfaces for most of the [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] [[components>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Component.WebHome]] required to support the data sharing vision.
++Such an architecture needs to be well organised, and the SDMX Registry/Repository (SDMXRR) is tasked with providing structure, organisation, and maintenance and query interfaces for most of the SDMX components required to support the data sharing vision.
--However, it is important to emphasise that the [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]]-RR provides support for the submission and retrieval of all [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]] and provisioning metadata. Therefore, the Registry not only supports the data-sharing scenario, but this metadata is also vital in order to provide support for data and metadata reporting/collection, and dissemination scenarios.
++However, it is important to emphasise that the SDMX-RR provides support for the submission and retrieval of all SDMX structural metadata and provisioning metadata. Therefore, the Registry not only supports the data-sharing scenario, but this metadata is also vital in order to provide support for data and metadata reporting/collection, and dissemination scenarios.
--Standard formats for the exchange of aggregated statistical data and metadata as prescribed in [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] v3.0 are envisaged to bring benefits to the statistical community because data reporting and dissemination processes can be made more efficient.
++Standard formats for the exchange of aggregated statistical data and metadata as prescribed in SDMX v3.0 are envisaged to bring benefits to the statistical community because data reporting and dissemination processes can be made more efficient.
--As organisations migrate to [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] enabled systems, many XML, JSON (and conventional) [[artefacts>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Artefact.WebHome]] will be produced (e.g., Data Structure, Metadata Structure, [[Code List>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Code list.WebHome]] and (% style="color:#2ecc71" %)Concept(%%) definitions – often collectively called [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]] – XML schemas generated from [[data structure definitions>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Data structure definition.WebHome]], XSLT stylesheets for transformation and display of data and metadata, terminology references, etc.). The [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] model supports interoperability, and it is important to be able to discover and share these [[artefacts>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Artefact.WebHome]] between parties in a controlled and organized way.
++As organisations migrate to SDMX enabled systems, many XML, JSON (and conventional) artefacts will be produced (e.g., Data Structure, Metadata Structure, Code List and Concept definitions – often collectively called structural metadata – XML schemas generated from data structure definitions, XSLT stylesheets for transformation and display of data and metadata, terminology references, etc.). The SDMX model supports interoperability, and it is important to be able to discover and share these artefacts between parties in a controlled and organized way.
  This is the role of the registry.
--With the fundamental [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] standards in place, a set of architectural standards are needed to address some of the processes involved in [[statistical data and metadata exchange>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]], with an emphasis on maintenance, retrieval and sharing of the [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]]. In addition, the architectural standards support the registration and discovery of data and referential metadata.
++With the fundamental SDMX standards in place, a set of architectural standards are needed to address some of the processes involved in statistical data and metadata exchange, with an emphasis on maintenance, retrieval and sharing of the structural metadata. In addition, the architectural standards support the registration and discovery of data and referential metadata.
--These architectural standards address the ‘how’, rather than the ‘what’, and are aimed at enabling existing [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] standards to achieve their mission. The architectural standards address registry services, which initially comprise:
++These architectural standards address the ‘how’, rather than the ‘what’, and are aimed at enabling existing SDMX standards to achieve their mission. The architectural standards address registry services, which initially comprise:
--* [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]] repository
++* structural metadata repository
  * data and metadata registration
  * query
--The registry services outlined in this specification are designed to help the [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] community manage the proliferation of [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] assets and to support data sharing for reporting and dissemination.
++The registry services outlined in this specification are designed to help the SDMX community manage the proliferation of SDMX assets and to support data sharing for reporting and dissemination.
  = {{id name="_Toc93832"/}}2 Scope and Normative Status =
--The scope of this document is to specify the logical interfaces for the [[SDMX registry>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX Registry.WebHome]] in terms of the functions required and the data that may be present in the function call, and the behaviour expected of the registry.
++The scope of this document is to specify the logical interfaces for the SDMX registry in terms of the functions required and the data that may be present in the function call, and the behaviour expected of the registry.
  In this document, functions and behaviours of the Registry Interfaces are described in four ways:
  * in text
  * with tables
--* with UML diagrams excerpted from the [[SDMX Information Model>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX Information Model.WebHome]] ([[SDMX-IM>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX Information Model.WebHome]])
--* with UML diagrams that are not a part of the [[SDMX-IM>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX Information Model.WebHome]] but are included here for clarity and to aid implementations (these diagrams are clearly marked as “Logical Class Diagram ...”)
++* with UML diagrams excerpted from the SDMX Information Model (SDMX-IM)
++* with UML diagrams that are not a part of the SDMX-IM but are included here for clarity and to aid implementations (these diagrams are clearly marked as “Logical Class Diagram ...”)
  Whilst the introductory section contains some information on the role of the registry, it is assumed that the reader is familiar with the uses of a registry in providing shared metadata across a community of counterparties.
--Note that chapters 5 and 6 below contain normative rules regarding the Registry Interface and the identification of registry objects. Further, the minimum standard for access to the registry is via a REST interface (HTTP or HTTPS), as described in the appropriate sections. The [[notification>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Notification.WebHome]] mechanism must support e-mail and HTTP/HTTPS protocols as described. Normative registry interfaces are specified in the [[SDMX-ML>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX-ML.WebHome]] specification (Section 3 of the [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] Standard). All other sections of this document are informative.
++Note that chapters 5 and 6 below contain normative rules regarding the Registry Interface and the identification of registry objects. Further, the minimum standard for access to the registry is via a REST interface (HTTP or HTTPS), as described in the appropriate sections. The notification mechanism must support e-mail and HTTP/HTTPS protocols as described. Normative registry interfaces are specified in the SDMX-ML specification (Section 3 of the SDMX Standard). All other sections of this document are informative.
--Note that although the term “authorised user” is used in this document, the [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]] standards do not define an access control mechanism. Such a mechanism, if required, must be chosen and implemented by the registry software provider.
++Note that although the term “authorised user” is used in this document, the SDMX standards do not define an access control mechanism. Such a mechanism, if required, must be chosen and implemented by the registry software provider.
  = {{id name="_Toc93833"/}}3 Scope of the SDMX Registry/Repository =
  == {{id name="_Toc93834"/}}3.1 Objective ==
--The objective of the [[SDMX registry>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.SDMX Registry.WebHome]]/repository is, in broad terms, to allow organisations to publish statistical data and [[reference metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Reference metadata.WebHome]] in known formats such that interested third parties can discover these data and interpret them accurately and correctly. The mechanism for doing this is twofold:
++The objective of the SDMX registry/repository is, in broad terms, to allow organisations to publish statistical data and reference metadata in known formats such that interested third parties can discover these data and interpret them accurately and correctly. The mechanism for doing this is twofold:
--1. To maintain and publish [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]] that describes the structure and valid content of data and [[reference metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Reference metadata.WebHome]] sources such as databases, [[metadata repositories>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Metadata repository.WebHome]], [[data sets>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Data set.WebHome]], [[metadata sets>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Metadata set.WebHome]]. This [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]] enables software applications to understand and to interpret the data and [[reference metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Reference metadata.WebHome]] in these sources.
--1. To enable applications, organisations, and individuals to share and to discover data and [[reference metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Reference metadata.WebHome]]. This facilitates data and [[reference metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Reference metadata.WebHome]] dissemination by implementing the data sharing vision of [[SDMX>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Statistical data and metadata exchange.WebHome]].
++1. To maintain and publish structural metadata that describes the structure and valid content of data and reference metadata sources such as databases, metadata repositories, data sets, metadata sets. This structural metadata enables software applications to understand and to interpret the data and reference metadata in these sources.
++1. To enable applications, organisations, and individuals to share and to discover data and reference metadata. This facilitates data and reference metadata dissemination by implementing the data sharing vision of SDMX.
  == {{id name="_Toc93835"/}}3.2 Structural Metadata ==
--Setting up [[structural metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Structural metadata.WebHome]] and the exchange context (referred to as “data provisioning”) involves the following steps for [[maintenance agencies>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Maintenance agency.WebHome]]:
++Setting up structural metadata and the exchange context (referred to as “data provisioning”) involves the following steps for maintenance agencies:
--* agreeing and creating a specification of the structure of the data (called a [[Data Structure Definition>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Data structure definition.WebHome]] or [[DSD>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Data structure definition.WebHome]] in this document but also known as “key family”), which defines the [[dimensions>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Dimension.WebHome]], [[measures>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Measure.WebHome]] and [[attributes>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Attribute.WebHome]] of a [[dataset>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Data set.WebHome]] and their valid value set;
--* if required, defining a subset or view of a [[DSD>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Data structure definition.WebHome]] which allows some restriction of content called a “[[dataflow>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Dataflow.WebHome]] definition”;
--* agreeing and creating a specification of the structure of [[reference metadata>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Reference metadata.WebHome]] ([[Metadata Structure Definition>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Metadata structure definition.WebHome]]) which defines the metadata [[attributes>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Attribute.WebHome]] and their presentational arrangement in a Metadataset or as part of a [[Dataset>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Data set.WebHome]], and their valid values and content;
--* if required, defining a subset or view of an [[MSD>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Metadata structure definition.WebHome]] which allows some restriction of content called a “[[metadataflow>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Metadataflow.WebHome]]”;
--* defining which subject matter domains (specified as a [[Category Scheme>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Category scheme.WebHome]]) are related to the [[Dataflow>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Dataflow.WebHome]] and [[Metadataflow>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Metadataflow.WebHome]] to enable browsing;
++* agreeing and creating a specification of the structure of the data (called a Data Structure Definition or DSD in this document but also known as “key family”), which defines the dimensions, measures and attributes of a dataset and their valid value set;
++* if required, defining a subset or view of a DSD which allows some restriction of content called a “dataflow definition”;
++* agreeing and creating a specification of the structure of reference metadata (Metadata Structure Definition) which defines the metadata attributes and their presentational arrangement in a Metadataset or as part of a Dataset, and their valid values and content;
++* if required, defining a subset or view of an MSD which allows some restriction of content called a “metadataflow”;
++* defining which subject matter domains (specified as a Category Scheme) are related to the Dataflow and Metadataflow to enable browsing;
  * defining one or more lists of Data and Metadata Providers;
--* defining which Data/Metadata Providers have agreed to publish a given [[Dataflow>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Dataflow.WebHome]]/[[Metadataflow>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Metadataflow.WebHome]] – this is called a [[Provision Agreement>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Provision agreement.WebHome]] or Metadata [[Provision Agreement>>doc:xwiki:Glossary.Provision agreement.WebHome]], respectively.
++* defining which Data/Metadata Providers have agreed to publish a given Dataflow/Metadataflow – this is called a Provision Agreement or Metadata Provision Agreement, respectively.
  [[image:SDMX 3-0-0 SECTION 5 FINAL-1.0_en_28806f51.jpg||height="539" width="443"]]
@@ -184,11 +184,11 @@
  === {{id name="_Toc93847"/}}5.2.2 Structure Submission Service ===
--The registry must support a mechanism for submitting structural metadata. This mechanism can be the SDMX REST interface for structural metadata (this is defined in the corresponding GitHub project, dedicated to the SDMX REST API: [[__https:~~/~~/github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest__>>https://https:github.comsdmx-twgsdmx-rest]]). In order for the architecture to be scalable, the finest-grained piece of structural metadata that can be processed by the SDMX-RR is a MaintainableArtefact, with the exception of Item Schemes, where changes at an Item level is also possible (see next section on the SDMX Information Model).
++The registry must support a mechanism for submitting structural metadata. This mechanism can be the SDMX REST interface for structural metadata (this is defined in the corresponding GitHub project, dedicated to the SDMX REST API: __[[https:~~/~~/github.com/sdmx>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[->>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[twg/sdmx>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[->>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[rest>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]]__[[)>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]]. In order for the architecture to be scalable, the finest-grained piece of structural metadata that can be processed by the SDMX-RR is a MaintainableArtefact, with the exception of Item Schemes, where changes at an Item level is also possible (see next section on the SDMX Information Model).
  === {{id name="_Toc93848"/}}5.2.3 Structure Query Service ===
--The registry must support a mechanism for querying for structural metadata. This mechanism can be the SDMX REST interface for structural metadata (this is defined in the corresponding GitHub project, dedicated to the SDMX REST API: [[__https:~~/~~/github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest__>>https://https:github.comsdmx-twgsdmx-rest]]). The registry response to this query mechanism is the SDMX Structure message, which has as its root node:
++The registry must support a mechanism for querying for structural metadata. This mechanism can be the SDMX REST interface for structural metadata (this is defined in the corresponding GitHub project, dedicated to the SDMX REST API: __[[https:~~/~~/github.com/sdmx>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[->>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[twg/sdmx>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[->>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]][[rest>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]]__ [[)>>url:https://github.com/sdmx-twg/sdmx-rest]]. The registry response to this query mechanism is the SDMX Structure message, which has as its root node:
  * Structure
@@ -281,7 +281,7 @@
  Subscription management involves a user submitting a subscription request which contains:
  * a query or constraint expression in terms of a filter which defines the events for which the user is interested (e.g., new data for a specific dataflow, or for a domain category, or changes to a Data Structure Definition).
--* a list of URIs or endpoints to which an XML notification message can be sent. Supported endpoint types will be email (mailto~: ) and HTTP POST (a normal http:~/~/ address);
++* a list of URIs or endpoints to which an XML notification message can be sent. Supported endpoint types will be email (mailto~:) and HTTP POST (a normal http:~/~/ address);
  * request for a list of submitted subscriptions;
  * deletion of a subscription;
@@ -302,8 +302,10 @@
  a) Be a draft version.
  )))
++|(% style="width:188px" %)**Interface**|(% style="width:542px" %)**Behaviour**
  |(% style="width:188px" %) |(% style="width:542px" %)(((
  b) Not be explicitly{{footnote}}With semantic versioning, it is allowed to reference a range of artefacts, e.g., a DSD referencing a Codelist with version 1.2.3+ means all patch versions greater than 1.2.3. This means that deleting 1.2.4-draft does not break integrity of the aforementioned DSD.{{/footnote}} referenced from any other object in the Registry.
++
 ) The semantic versioning rules in the SDMX documentation MUST be obeyed.
  )))
  |(% style="width:188px" %)Structure submission|(% style="width:542px" %)Structures are submitted at the level of the Maintainable Artefact and the behaviour in “All” above is therefore at the level of the Maintainable Artefact.
@@ -328,12 +328,14 @@
  The table below shows the identification and related data attributes to be stored in a registry for objects that are one of:
--* //nnotable//
++* //Annotable//
  * //Identifiable//
  * //Nameable//
  * //Versionable//
  * //Maintainable//
++:
++
  (((
  (% style="width:1052.29px" %)
  |**Object Type**|(% style="width:241px" %)**Data Attributes**|(% style="width:156px" %)**Status**|**Data type**|(% style="width:457px" %)**Notes**
@@ -361,9 +361,9 @@
  **Table 1: Common Attributes of Object Types**
--== {{id name="_Toc93856"/}}6.2 Unique identification of SDMX objects ==
++=== {{id name="_Toc93856"/}}6.2 Unique identification of SDMX objects ===
--=== {{id name="_Toc93857"/}}6.2.1 Agencies and Metadata Providers ===
++===== {{id name="_Toc93857"/}}6.2.1 Agencies and Metadata Providers =====
  The Maintenance Agency in SDMX is maintained in an Agency Scheme which itself is a sub class of Organisation Scheme – this is shown in the class diagram below.
@@ -444,14 +444,23 @@
  The packages are:
  base
++
  codelist
++
  conceptscheme
++
  datastructure
++
  categoryscheme
++
  registry
++
  metadatastructure
++
  process
++
  structuremapping
++
  transformation
  **maintainable-object-id** is the identifier of the maintainable object. This will always be present as all identifiable objects are either a maintainable object or contained in a maintainable object.
@@ -496,23 +496,23 @@
  The Data Structure Definition CRED_EXT_DEBT of legacy version 2.1 maintained by the toplevel Agency TFFS would have the URN:
--       urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.datastructure.DataStucture=TFFS:CRED_EXT_ DEBT(2.1)
++urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.datastructure.DataStucture=TFFS:CRED_EXT_ DEBT(2.1)
  The URN for a code for Argentina maintained by ISO in the code list CL_3166A2 of semantic version 1.0.0 would be:
--        urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.codelist.Code=ISO:CL_3166A2(1.0.0).AR
++urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.codelist.Code=ISO:CL_3166A2(1.0.0).AR
  The URN for a category (id of 1) which has parent category (id of 2) maintained by SDMX in the category scheme SUBJECT_MATTER_DOMAINS of the semantic extended version 1.0.0draft would be:
--        urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.categoryscheme.Category=SDMX:SUBJECT_MATT ER_DOMAINS(1.0.0-draft).1.2
++urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.categoryscheme.Category=SDMX:SUBJECT_MATT ER_DOMAINS(1.0.0-draft).1.2
  The URN for a Metadata Attribute maintained by SDMX in the MSD CONTACT_METADATA of semantic version 1.0.0 where the hierarchy of the Metadata Attribute is CONTACT_DETAILS/CONTACT_NAME would be:
--       urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.metadatastructure.MetadataAttribute=SDMX: CONTACT_METADATA(1.0.0).CONTACT_DETAILS.CONTACT_NAME
++urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.metadatastructure.MetadataAttribute=SDMX: CONTACT_METADATA(1.0.0).CONTACT_DETAILS.CONTACT_NAME
  The TFFS defines ABC as a sub-Agency of TFFS then the URN of a Dataflow maintained by ABC and identified as EXTERNAL_DEBT of semantic version 1.0.0 would be:
--       urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.datastructure.Dataflow=TFFS.ABC:EXTERNAL_ DEBT(1.0.0)
++urn:sdmx:org.sdmx.infomodel.datastructure.Dataflow=TFFS.ABC:EXTERNAL_ DEBT(1.0.0)
  The SDMX-RR MUST support this globally unique identification scheme. The SDMX-RR MUST be able to create the URN from the individual identification attributes submitted and to transform the URN to these identification attributes. The identification attributes are:
@@ -612,108 +612,118 @@
  urn:sdmx.org.sdmx.infomodel.{package}.{classname}=
--(% style="width:1419.29px" %)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)**Classname**|(% style="width:645px" %)**Ending URN pattern**|(% style="width:543px" %)**Example**
--|(% style="width:227px" %)Agency{{footnote}}The identification of an Agency in the URN structure for the maintainable object is by means of the agencyId. The AgencyScheme is not identified as SDMX has a mechanism for identifying an Agency uniquely by its Id. Note that this Id may be hierarchical. For example, a sub-agency of IMF is referred like this: IMF.SubAgency1{{/footnote}}|(% style="width:645px" %)agencySchemeAgencyId:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**).agencyId|(% style="width:543px" %)ECB:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**).AA
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//AgencyScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)agencySchemeAgencyId:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**)|(% style="width:543px" %)ECB:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//Categorisation//|(% style="width:645px" %)categorisationAgencyId:categorisationId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:cat001(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)Category|(% style="width:645px" %)categorySchemeAgencyId:categorySchemeId(versi on).categoryId.categoryId.categoryId etc.|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:SDDS(1.0.0):level_1_category.level_2_category …
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//CategoryScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)categorySchemeAgencyId:categorySchemeId(versi on)|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:SDDS(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//CategorySchemeMap//|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++(% style="width:1311.29px" %)
++|(% style="width:252px" %)**Classname**|(% style="width:639px" %)**Ending URN pattern**|(% style="width:418px" %)**Example**
++|(% style="width:252px" %)Agency{{footnote}}The identification of an Agency in the URN structure for the maintainable object is by means of the agencyId. The AgencyScheme is not identified as SDMX has a mechanism for identifying an Agency uniquely by its Id. Note that this Id may be hierarchical. For example, a sub-agency of IMF is referred like this: IMF.SubAgency1{{/footnote}}|(% style="width:639px" %)agencySchemeAgencyId:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**).agencyId|(% style="width:418px" %)ECB:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**).AA
++|(% style="width:252px" %)//AgencyScheme//|(% style="width:639px" %)agencySchemeAgencyId:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**)|(% style="width:418px" %)ECB:**AGENCIES**(**1.0**)
++|(% style="width:252px" %)//Categorisation//|(% style="width:639px" %)categorisationAgencyId:categorisationId(version)|(% style="width:418px" %)IMF:cat001(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:252px" %)Category|(% style="width:639px" %)categorySchemeAgencyId:categorySchemeId(versi on).categoryId.categoryId.categoryId etc.|(% style="width:418px" %)IMF:SDDS(1.0.0):level_1_category.level_2_category …
++|(% style="width:252px" %)//CategoryScheme//|(% style="width:639px" %)categorySchemeAgencyId:categorySchemeId(versi on)|(% style="width:418px" %)IMF:SDDS(1.0.0)
++
++|(% style="width:250px" %)**Classname**|(% style="width:639px" %)**Ending URN pattern**|(% style="width:1049px" %)**Example**
++|(% style="width:250px" %)//CategorySchemeMap//|(% style="width:639px" %)(((
  catSchemeMapAgencyId:catSchemeMapId(version)
--)))|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:EUROSTAT_SUBJECT_DOMAIN(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)Code|(% style="width:645px" %)codeListAgencyId:codelistId(version).codeId|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:CL_FREQ(1.0.0).Q
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//Codelist//|(% style="width:645px" %)codeListAgencyId:codeListId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:CL_FREQ(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)ComponentMap|(% style="width:645px" %)structureMapAgencyId:structureMap(version).com ponentMapId|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:BOP_STRUCTURES(1.0.0).REF_AREA_TO_COUNT RY
--|(% style="width:227px" %)Concept|(% style="width:645px" %)conceptSchemeAgencyId:conceptSchemeId(versio n).conceptId|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:CROSS_DOMAIN_CONCEPTS(1.0.0).FREQ
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//ConceptScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)conceptSchemeAgencyId:conceptSchemeId(versio n)|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:CROSS_DOMAIN_CONCEPTS(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//ConceptSchemeMap//|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1049px" %)SDMX:EUROSTAT_SUBJECT_DOMAIN(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:250px" %)Code|(% style="width:639px" %)codeListAgencyId:codelistId(version).codeId|(% style="width:1049px" %)SDMX:CL_FREQ(1.0.0).Q
++|(% style="width:250px" %)//Codelist//|(% style="width:639px" %)codeListAgencyId:codeListId(version)|(% style="width:1049px" %)SDMX:CL_FREQ(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:250px" %)ComponentMap|(% style="width:639px" %)structureMapAgencyId:structureMap(version).com ponentMapId|(% style="width:1049px" %)SDMX:BOP_STRUCTURES(1.0.0).REF_AREA_TO_COUNT RY
++|(% style="width:250px" %)Concept|(% style="width:639px" %)conceptSchemeAgencyId:conceptSchemeId(versio n).conceptId|(% style="width:1049px" %)SDMX:CROSS_DOMAIN_CONCEPTS(1.0.0).FREQ
++|(% style="width:250px" %)//ConceptScheme//|(% style="width:639px" %)conceptSchemeAgencyId:conceptSchemeId(versio n)|(% style="width:1049px" %)SDMX:CROSS_DOMAIN_CONCEPTS(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:250px" %)//ConceptSchemeMap//|(% style="width:639px" %)(((
  conceptSchemeMapAgencyId:conceptSchemeMap
  Id(version)
--)))|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:CONCEPT_MAP(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)CustomType|(% style="width:645px" %)customTypeSchemeAgencyId customTypeSchemeId(version) customTypeId|(% style="width:543px" %)ECB: CUSTOM_TYPE_SCHEME(1.0.0).CUSTOM_TYPE_1
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//CustomTypeScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)customTypeSchemeAgencyId customTypeSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)ECB:CUSTOM_TYPE_SCHEME(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)DataAttrribute|(% style="width:645px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).dataAttributeId|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).OBS_STATUS
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//DataConstraint//|(% style="width:645px" %)dataConstraintAgencyId:dataConstraintId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:CREDITOR_DATA_CONTENT(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)DataConsumer|(% style="width:645px" %)dataConsumerSchemeAgencyId:**DATA_CONSUME RS**(**1.0**).dataConsumerId|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:**DATA_CONSUMERS**(**1.0**).CONSUMER_1
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//DataConsumerScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1049px" %)SDMX:CONCEPT_MAP(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:250px" %)CustomType|(% style="width:639px" %)customTypeSchemeAgencyId customTypeSchemeId(version) customTypeId|(% style="width:1049px" %)ECB: CUSTOM_TYPE_SCHEME(1.0.0).CUSTOM_TYPE_1
++|(% style="width:250px" %)//CustomTypeScheme//|(% style="width:639px" %)customTypeSchemeAgencyId customTypeSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1049px" %)ECB:CUSTOM_TYPE_SCHEME(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:250px" %)DataAttrribute|(% style="width:639px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).dataAttributeId|(% style="width:1049px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).OBS_STATUS
++|(% style="width:250px" %)//DataConstraint//|(% style="width:639px" %)dataConstraintAgencyId:dataConstraintId(version)|(% style="width:1049px" %)TFFS:CREDITOR_DATA_CONTENT(1.0.0)
++
++|(% style="width:248px" %)**Classname**|(% style="width:643px" %)**Ending URN pattern**|(% style="width:1047px" %)**Example**
++|(% style="width:248px" %)DataConsumer|(% style="width:643px" %)dataConsumerSchemeAgencyId:**DATA_CONSUME RS**(**1.0**).dataConsumerId|(% style="width:1047px" %)SDMX:**DATA_CONSUMERS**(**1.0**).CONSUMER_1
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//DataConsumerScheme//|(% style="width:643px" %)(((
  dataConsumerSchemeAgencyId:**DATA_CONSUME RS**(**1.0**)
--)))|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:**DATA_CONSUMERS**(**1.0**)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//Dataflow//|(% style="width:645px" %)dataflowAgencyId:dataflowId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:CRED_EXT_DEBT(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)DataProvider|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1047px" %)SDMX:**DATA_CONSUMERS**(**1.0**)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//Dataflow//|(% style="width:643px" %)dataflowAgencyId:dataflowId(version)|(% style="width:1047px" %)TFFS:CRED_EXT_DEBT(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)DataProvider|(% style="width:643px" %)(((
  dataProviderSchemeAgencyId:**DATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**).dataProviderId
--)))|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:**DATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**).PROVIDER_1
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//DataProviderScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1047px" %)SDMX:**DATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**).PROVIDER_1
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//DataProviderScheme//|(% style="width:643px" %)(((
  dataProviderSchemeAgencyId:**DATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**)
--)))|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:**DATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//DataStructure//|(% style="width:645px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)Dimension|(% style="width:645px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).dimensionId|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).FREQ
--|(% style="width:229px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1047px" %)SDMX:**DATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//DataStructure//|(% style="width:643px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version)|(% style="width:1047px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)Dimension|(% style="width:643px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).dimensionId|(% style="width:1047px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).FREQ
++|(% style="width:248px" %)(((
  DimensionDescriptor
  MeasureDescriptor
  AttributeDescriptor
--)))|(% style="width:645px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).componentListId where the componentListId is the name of the class (there is only one occurrence of each in the Data Structure Definition)|(% style="width:543px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:643px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).componentListId where the componentListId is the name of the class (there is only one occurrence of each in the Data Structure Definition)|(% style="width:1047px" %)(((
  TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).DimensionDescriptor
  TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).MeasureDescriptor
  TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).AttributeDescriptor
  )))
--|(% style="width:229px" %)GroupDimensionDescriptor|(% style="width:645px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).groupDimensionDescriptorId|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).SIBLING
--|(% style="width:229px" %)HierarchicalCode|(% style="width:645px" %)hierarchyAgencyId:hierarchyId(version).hierarchica lCode.hierarchicalCode|(% style="width:543px" %)UNESCO:H-C-GOV(1.0.0).GOV_CODE1.GOV_CODE1_1
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//Hierarchy//|(% style="width:645px" %)hierarchyAgencyId:hierarchyId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)UNESCO:H-C-GOV(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//HierarchyAssociation//|(% style="width:645px" %)hierarchyAssociationAgencyId:hierarchyAssociatio nId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)UNESCO:CL_EXP_SOURCE(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:206px" %)Level|(% style="width:645px" %)hierarchyAgencyId:hierarchyId(version).level|(% style="width:543px" %)UNESCO:H-C-GOV(1.0.0).LVL1
--|(% style="width:206px" %)Measure|(% style="width:645px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).measureId|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).OBS_VALUE
--|(% style="width:206px" %)MetadataAttribute|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++|(% style="width:248px" %)GroupDimensionDescriptor|(% style="width:643px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).groupDimensionDescriptorId|(% style="width:1047px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).SIBLING
++|(% style="width:248px" %)HierarchicalCode|(% style="width:643px" %)hierarchyAgencyId:hierarchyId(version).hierarchica lCode.hierarchicalCode|(% style="width:1047px" %)UNESCO:H-C-GOV(1.0.0).GOV_CODE1.GOV_CODE1_1
++
++|(% style="width:248px" %)**Classname**|(% style="width:646px" %)**Ending URN pattern**|(% style="width:1044px" %)**Example**
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//Hierarchy//|(% style="width:646px" %)hierarchyAgencyId:hierarchyId(version)|(% style="width:1044px" %)UNESCO:H-C-GOV(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//HierarchyAssociation//|(% style="width:646px" %)hierarchyAssociationAgencyId:hierarchyAssociatio nId(version)|(% style="width:1044px" %)UNESCO:CL_EXP_SOURCE(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)Level|(% style="width:646px" %)hierarchyAgencyId:hierarchyId(version).level|(% style="width:1044px" %)UNESCO:H-C-GOV(1.0.0).LVL1
++|(% style="width:248px" %)Measure|(% style="width:646px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).measureId|(% style="width:1044px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).OBS_VALUE
++|(% style="width:248px" %)MetadataAttribute|(% style="width:646px" %)(((
  msdAgencyId:msdId(version).metadataAttributeId.
  metadataAttributeId
--)))|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:SDDS_MSD(1.0.0).COMPILATION.METHOD
--|(% style="width:206px" %)MetadataAttributeDescriptor|(% style="width:645px" %)msdAgencyId:msdId(version).metadataAttributeDe scriptorId|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:SDDS_MSD(1.0.0).MetadataAttributeDescriptor
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//MetadataConstraint//|(% style="width:645px" %)metadataConstraintAgencyId:metadataConstraintI d(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)TFFS:CREDITOR_METADATA_CONTENT(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//Metadataflow//|(% style="width:645px" %)metadataflowAgencyId:metadataflowId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:SDDS_MDF(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:206px" %)MetadataProvider|(% style="width:645px" %)metadataProviderSchemeAgencyId:**METADATA_P ROVIDERS**(**1.0**).metadataProviderId|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:**METADATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**).MD_PROVIDER_1
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//MetadataProviderScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)metadataProviderSchemeAgencyId:**METADATA_P ROVIDERS**(**1.0**)|(% style="width:543px" %)SDMX:**METADATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**)
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//MetadataProvisionAgreement//|(% style="width:645px" %)metadataProvisionAgreementAgencyId:metadataP rovisionAgreementId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:SDDS_MDF_AB(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//MetadataSet//|(% style="width:645px" %)metadataProviderId:metadataSetId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)MD_PROVIDER:METADATASET(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:206px" %)//MetadataStructure//|(% style="width:645px" %)msdAgencyId:msdId(version)|(% style="width:543px" %)IMF:SDDS_MSD(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)NamePersonalisation|(% style="width:527px" %)namePersonalisationSchemeAgencyId namePersonalisationSchemeId(version) namePersonalisationId|(% style="width:545px" %)ECB:PSN_SCHEME(1.0.0).PSN1234
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//NamePersonalisationScheme//|(% style="width:527px" %)namePersonalisationSchemeAgencyId namePersonalisationSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:545px" %)ECB:PSN_SCHEME(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//OrganisationSchemeMap//|(% style="width:527px" %)orgSchemeMapAgencyId:orgSchemeMapId(versio n)|(% style="width:545px" %)SDMX:AGENCIES_PROVIDERS(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)OrganisationUnit|(% style="width:527px" %)organisationUnitSchemeAgencyId:organisationUnitSchemeId(version).organisationUnitId|(% style="width:545px" %)ECB:ORGANISATIONS(1.0.0).1F
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//OrganisationUnitScheme//|(% style="width:527px" %)organisationUnitSchemeAgencyId:organisationUni tSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:545px" %)ECB:ORGANISATIONS(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//Process//|(% style="width:527px" %)processAgencyId:processId{version)|(% style="width:545px" %)BIS:PROCESS1(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)ProcessStep|(% style="width:527px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1044px" %)IMF:SDDS_MSD(1.0.0).COMPILATION.METHOD
++|(% style="width:248px" %)MetadataAttributeDescriptor|(% style="width:646px" %)msdAgencyId:msdId(version).metadataAttributeDe scriptorId|(% style="width:1044px" %)IMF:SDDS_MSD(1.0.0).MetadataAttributeDescriptor
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//MetadataConstraint//|(% style="width:646px" %)metadataConstraintAgencyId:metadataConstraintI d(version)|(% style="width:1044px" %)TFFS:CREDITOR_METADATA_CONTENT(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//Metadataflow//|(% style="width:646px" %)metadataflowAgencyId:metadataflowId(version)|(% style="width:1044px" %)IMF:SDDS_MDF(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)MetadataProvider|(% style="width:646px" %)metadataProviderSchemeAgencyId:**METADATA_P ROVIDERS**(**1.0**).metadataProviderId|(% style="width:1044px" %)SDMX:**METADATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**).MD_PROVIDER_1
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//MetadataProviderScheme//|(% style="width:646px" %)metadataProviderSchemeAgencyId:**METADATA_P ROVIDERS**(**1.0**)|(% style="width:1044px" %)SDMX:**METADATA_PROVIDERS**(**1.0**)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//MetadataProvisionAgreement//|(% style="width:646px" %)metadataProvisionAgreementAgencyId:metadataP rovisionAgreementId(version)|(% style="width:1044px" %)IMF:SDDS_MDF_AB(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//MetadataSet//|(% style="width:646px" %)metadataProviderId:metadataSetId(version)|(% style="width:1044px" %)MD_PROVIDER:METADATASET(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//MetadataStructure//|(% style="width:646px" %)msdAgencyId:msdId(version)|(% style="width:1044px" %)IMF:SDDS_MSD(1.0.0)
++
++|(% style="width:248px" %)**Classname**|(% style="width:629px" %)**Ending URN pattern**|(% style="width:1061px" %)**Example**
++|(% style="width:248px" %)NamePersonalisation|(% style="width:629px" %)namePersonalisationSchemeAgencyId namePersonalisationSchemeId(version) namePersonalisationId|(% style="width:1061px" %)ECB:PSN_SCHEME(1.0.0).PSN1234
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//NamePersonalisationScheme//|(% style="width:629px" %)namePersonalisationSchemeAgencyId namePersonalisationSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1061px" %)ECB:PSN_SCHEME(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//OrganisationSchemeMap//|(% style="width:629px" %)orgSchemeMapAgencyId:orgSchemeMapId(versio n)|(% style="width:1061px" %)SDMX:AGENCIES_PROVIDERS(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)OrganisationUnit|(% style="width:629px" %)organisationUnitSchemeAgencyId:organisationUnitSchemeId(version).organisationUnitId|(% style="width:1061px" %)ECB:ORGANISATIONS(1.0.0).1F
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//OrganisationUnitScheme//|(% style="width:629px" %)organisationUnitSchemeAgencyId:organisationUni tSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1061px" %)ECB:ORGANISATIONS(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//Process//|(% style="width:629px" %)processAgencyId:processId{version)|(% style="width:1061px" %)BIS:PROCESS1(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)ProcessStep|(% style="width:629px" %)(((
  processAgencyId:processId(version).processStepId.
  processStepId
--)))|(% style="width:545px" %)BIS:PROCESS1(1.0.0).STEP1.STEP1_1
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//ProvisionAgreement//|(% style="width:527px" %)provisionAgreementAgencyId:provisionAgreement Id(version)|(% style="width:545px" %)TFFS:CRED_EXT_DEBT_AB(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)ReportingCategory|(% style="width:527px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1061px" %)BIS:PROCESS1(1.0.0).STEP1.STEP1_1
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//ProvisionAgreement//|(% style="width:629px" %)provisionAgreementAgencyId:provisionAgreement Id(version)|(% style="width:1061px" %)TFFS:CRED_EXT_DEBT_AB(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)ReportingCategory|(% style="width:629px" %)(((
  reportingTaxonomyAgencyId:
  reportingTaxonomyId(version).reportingCategoryI d.reportingCategoryId
--)))|(% style="width:545px" %)IMF:REP_1(1.0.0):LVL1_REP_CAT.LVL2_REP_CAT
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//ReportingTaxonomy//|(% style="width:527px" %)reportingTaxonomyAgencyId:reportingTaxonomyI d(version)|(% style="width:545px" %)IMF:REP_1(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:227px" %)//ReportingTaxonomyMap//|(% style="width:527px" %)repTaxonomyAgencyId:repTaxonomyId(version)|(% style="width:545px" %)SDMX:RT_MAP(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//RepresentationMap//|(% style="width:645px" %)repMapAgencyId:repMapId(version)|(% style="width:215px" %)SDMX:REF_AREA_MAPPING(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)Ruleset|(% style="width:645px" %)rulesetSchemeAgencyId rulesetSchemeId(version) rulesetId|(% style="width:215px" %)ECB:RULESET_23(1.0.0).SET111
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//RulesetScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)rulesetSchemeAgencyId rulesetSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:215px" %)ECB:RULESET_23(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//StructureMap//|(% style="width:645px" %)structureMapAgencyId:structureMap(version)|(% style="width:215px" %)SDMX:BOP_STRUCTURES(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)Subscription|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1061px" %)IMF:REP_1(1.0.0):LVL1_REP_CAT.LVL2_REP_CAT
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//ReportingTaxonomy//|(% style="width:629px" %)reportingTaxonomyAgencyId:reportingTaxonomyI d(version)|(% style="width:1061px" %)IMF:REP_1(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:248px" %)//ReportingTaxonomyMap//|(% style="width:629px" %)repTaxonomyAgencyId:repTaxonomyId(version)|(% style="width:1061px" %)SDMX:RT_MAP(1.0.0)
++
++|(% style="width:247px" %)**Classname**|(% style="width:649px" %)**Ending URN pattern**|(% style="width:1042px" %)**Example**
++|(% style="width:247px" %)//RepresentationMap//|(% style="width:649px" %)repMapAgencyId:repMapId(version)|(% style="width:1042px" %)SDMX:REF_AREA_MAPPING(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:247px" %)Ruleset|(% style="width:649px" %)rulesetSchemeAgencyId rulesetSchemeId(version) rulesetId|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:RULESET_23(1.0.0).SET111
++|(% style="width:247px" %)//RulesetScheme//|(% style="width:649px" %)rulesetSchemeAgencyId rulesetSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:RULESET_23(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:247px" %)//StructureMap//|(% style="width:649px" %)structureMapAgencyId:structureMap(version)|(% style="width:1042px" %)SDMX:BOP_STRUCTURES(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:247px" %)Subscription|(% style="width:649px" %)(((
  The Subscription is not itself an Identifiable Artefact and therefore it does not follow the rules for URN structure.
  The name of the URN is registryURN There is no pre-determined format.
--)))|(% style="width:1015px" %)This cannot be generated by a common mechanism as subscriptions, although maintainable in the sense that they can be submitted and deleted, are not mandated to be created by a maintenance agency and have no versioning mechanism. It is therefore the responsibility of the target registry to generate a unique Id for the Subscription, and for the application creating the subscription to store the registry URN that is returned from the registry in the subscription response message.
--|(% style="width:229px" %)TimeDimension|(% style="width:645px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).timeDimensionId|(% style="width:1015px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).TIME_PERIOD
--|(% style="width:229px" %)Transformation|(% style="width:645px" %)transformationSchemeAgencyId transformationSchemeId(version) transformationId|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB:TRANSFORMATION_SCHEME(1.0.0).TRANS_1
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//TransformationScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)transformationSchemeAgencyId transformationSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB: TRANSFORMATION_SCHEME(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)Transition|(% style="width:645px" %)(((
++)))|(% style="width:1042px" %)This cannot be generated by a common mechanism as subscriptions, although maintainable in the sense that they can be submitted and deleted, are not mandated to be created by a maintenance agency and have no versioning mechanism. It is therefore the responsibility of the target registry to generate a unique Id for the Subscription, and for the application creating the subscription to store the registry URN that is returned from the registry in the subscription response message.
++|(% style="width:247px" %)TimeDimension|(% style="width:649px" %)dataStructureDefinitionAgencyId:dataStructureDef initionId(version).timeDimensionId|(% style="width:1042px" %)TFFS:EXT_DEBT(1.0.0).TIME_PERIOD
++|(% style="width:247px" %)Transformation|(% style="width:649px" %)transformationSchemeAgencyId transformationSchemeId(version) transformationId|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:TRANSFORMATION_SCHEME(1.0.0).TRANS_1
++|(% style="width:247px" %)//TransformationScheme//|(% style="width:649px" %)transformationSchemeAgencyId transformationSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB: TRANSFORMATION_SCHEME(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:247px" %)Transition|(% style="width:649px" %)(((
  processAgencyId:processId(version).processStepId.
  transitionId
--)))|(% style="width:1015px" %)BIS:PROCESS1(1.0.0).STEP1.TRANSITION1
--|(% style="width:229px" %)UserDefinedOperator|(% style="width:645px" %)userDefinedOperatorSchemeAgencyId userDefinedOperatorSchemeId(version) usserDefinedOperatorId|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB:OS_CALC(1.2.0).OS267
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//UserDefinedOperatorScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)userDefinedOperatorSchemeAgencyId userDefinedOperatorSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB:OS_CALC(1.2.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//ValueList//|(% style="width:645px" %)valuelistAgencyId:valuelistId(version)|(% style="width:1015px" %)SDMX:VLIST(1.0.0)
--|(% style="width:229px" %)VtlCodelistMapping|(% style="width:645px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId vtlMappingSchemeId(version) vtlCodelistMappingId|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(2.0.0).ABZ
--|(% style="width:229px" %)VtlConceptMapping|(% style="width:645px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId vtlMappingSchemeId(version) vtlConceptMappingId|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(1.0.0).XYA
--|(% style="width:229px" %)VtlDataflowMapping|(% style="width:645px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId vtlMappingSchemeId(version) vtlDataflowMappingId|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(1.0.0).MOQ
--|(% style="width:229px" %)//VtlMappingScheme//|(% style="width:645px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId VtlMappingSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1015px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(2.0.0)
++)))|(% style="width:1042px" %)BIS:PROCESS1(1.0.0).STEP1.TRANSITION1
++|(% style="width:247px" %)UserDefinedOperator|(% style="width:649px" %)userDefinedOperatorSchemeAgencyId userDefinedOperatorSchemeId(version) usserDefinedOperatorId|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:OS_CALC(1.2.0).OS267
++|(% style="width:247px" %)//UserDefinedOperatorScheme//|(% style="width:649px" %)userDefinedOperatorSchemeAgencyId userDefinedOperatorSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:OS_CALC(1.2.0)
++|(% style="width:247px" %)//ValueList//|(% style="width:649px" %)valuelistAgencyId:valuelistId(version)|(% style="width:1042px" %)SDMX:VLIST(1.0.0)
++|(% style="width:247px" %)VtlCodelistMapping|(% style="width:649px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId vtlMappingSchemeId(version) vtlCodelistMappingId|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(2.0.0).ABZ
++|(% style="width:247px" %)VtlConceptMapping|(% style="width:649px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId vtlMappingSchemeId(version) vtlConceptMappingId|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(1.0.0).XYA
++|(% style="width:247px" %)VtlDataflowMapping|(% style="width:649px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId vtlMappingSchemeId(version) vtlDataflowMappingId|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(1.0.0).MOQ
++|(% style="width:247px" %)//VtlMappingScheme//|(% style="width:649px" %)vtlMappingSchemeAgencyId VtlMappingSchemeId(version)|(% style="width:1042px" %)ECB:CLIST_MP(2.0.0)
  **Table 3: Table of identification components for SDMX Identifiable Artefacts**
@@ -721,7 +721,7 @@
  === {{id name="_Toc93862"/}}7.1 Structural Definition Metadata ===
--=== {{id name="_Toc93863"/}}7.1.1 Introduction ===
++===== {{id name="_Toc93863"/}}7.1.1 Introduction =====
  The SDMX Registry must have the ability to support agencies in their role of defining and disseminating structural metadata artefacts. These artefacts include data structure definitions, code lists, concepts etc. and are fully defined in the SDMX-IM. An authenticated agency may submit valid structural metadata definitions which must be stored in the registry. Note that the term “structural metadata” refers as a general term to all structural components (Data Structure Definitions, Metadata Structure Definitions, Code Lists, Concept Schemes, etc.)
@@ -788,7 +788,7 @@
  **Table 4: Table of Maintainable Artefacts for Structural Definition Metadata**
--=== {{id name="_Toc93864"/}}7.1.2 Item Scheme, Structure ===
++===== {{id name="_Toc93864"/}}7.1.2 Item Scheme, Structure =====
  The artefacts included in the structural definitions are:
@@ -797,19 +797,19 @@
  * All types of Structure (Data Structure Definition, Metadata Structure Definition)
  * All types of Structure Usage (Dataflow, Metadataflow)
--=== {{id name="_Toc93865"/}}7.1.3 Structure Usage ===
++===== {{id name="_Toc93865"/}}7.1.3 Structure Usage =====
--==== 7.1.3.1 Structure Usage: Basic Concepts ====
++**7.1.3.1 Structure Usage: Basic Concepts**
  The Structure Usage defines, in its concrete classes of Dataflow and Metadataflow, which flows of data and metadata use which specific Structure, and importantly for the support of data and metadata discovery, the Structure Usage can be linked to one or more Category in one or more Category Scheme using the Categorisation mechanism. This gives the ability for an application to discover data and metadata by “drilling down” the Category Schemes.
--==== 7.1.3.2 Structure Usage Schematic ====
++**7.1.3.2 Structure Usage Schematic**
  [[image:SDMX 3-0-0 SECTION 5 FINAL-1.0_en_52097ab5.jpg||height="246" width="438"]]
  **Figure 9: Schematic of Linking the Data and Metadata Flows to Categories and Structure Definitions**
--==== 7.1.3.3 Structure Usage Model ====
++**7.1.3.3 Structure Usage Model**
  [[image:SDMX 3-0-0 SECTION 5 FINAL-1.0_en_302cc1a2.jpg||height="548" width="578"]]
@@ -857,9 +857,9 @@
  A Provision Agreement is structural metadata. Each Provision Agreement must reference a Data Provider or Metadata Provider and a Dataflow or Metadataflow Definition. The Data/Metadata Provider and the Dataflow/Metadataflow must exist already in order to set up a Metadata Provision or Provision Agreement.
--== {{id name="_Toc93869"/}}7.3 Data and Metadata Constraints ==
++=== {{id name="_Toc93869"/}}7.3 Data and Metadata Constraints ===
--=== {{id name="_Toc93870"/}}7.3.1 Data and Metadata Constraints: Basic Concepts ===
++===== {{id name="_Toc93870"/}}7.3.1 Data and Metadata Constraints: Basic Concepts =====
  Constraints are, effectively, lists of the valid or actual content of data and metadata. Constraints can be used to specify a subset of the theoretical content of data set or metadata set which can be derived from the specification of the DSD or MSD. A Constraint can comprise a list of keys or a list of content (usually code values) of a specific component such as a dimension or attribute.
@@ -923,14 +923,17 @@
  The Registration has an action attribute which takes one of the following values:
++:
++
  (((
--(% style="width:761.294px" %)
--|(% style="width:196px" %)**Action Attribute Value**|(% style="width:561px" %)**Behaviour**
--|(% style="width:196px" %)Append|(% style="width:561px" %)Add this Registration to the registry
--|(% style="width:196px" %)Replace|(% style="width:561px" %)(((
--Replace the existing Registration with identified by the id in the Registration of the SubmitRegistrationRequest
++|**Action Attribute Value**|**Behaviour**
++|Append|Add this Registration to the registry
++|Replace|(((
++Replace the existing Registration with identified by the id in the
++
++Registration of the SubmitRegistrationRequest
  )))
--|(% style="width:196px" %)Delete|(% style="width:561px" %)Delete the existing Registration identified by the id in the Registration of the SubmitRegistrationRequest
++|Delete|Delete the existing Registration identified by the id in the Registration of the SubmitRegistrationRequest
  )))
  [[image:SDMX 3-0-0 SECTION 5 FINAL-1.0_en_bc1dcdec.jpg||height="575" width="579"]]
@@ -947,20 +947,27 @@
  Information in the data or metadata set is extracted and placed in one or more //Constraint//s (see the //Constraint// model in the SDMX Information Model – Section 2 of the SDMX Standards). The information to be extracted is indicated by the Boolean values set on the ProvisionAgreement or MetadataProvisionAgreement as shown in the table below.
++:
++
  (((
--(% style="width:678.294px" %)
--|**Indexing Required**|(% style="width:504px" %)**Registration Process Activity**
--|indexTimeSeries|(% style="width:504px" %)Extract all the series keys and create a KeySet(s) Constraint.
--|indexDataSet|(% style="width:504px" %)Extract all the codes and other content of the Key value of the Series Key in a Data Set and create one or more Cube Regions containing Member Selections of Dimension Components of the Constraints model in the SDMX-IM, and the associated Selection Value.
--|indexReportingPeriod|(% style="width:504px" %)(((
++|**Indexing Required**|**Registration Process Activity**
++|indexTimeSeries|Extract all the series keys and create a KeySet(s) Constraint.
++|indexDataSet|Extract all the codes and other content of the Key value of the Series Key in a Data Set and create one or more Cube Regions containing Member Selections of Dimension Components of the Constraints model in the SDMX-IM, and the associated Selection Value.
++|indexReportingPeriod|(((
  This applies only to a registered __dataset__.
++
  Extract the Reporting Begin and Reporting End from the Header of the Message containing the data set, and create a Reference Period constraint.
  )))
--|**Indexing Required**|(% style="width:504px" %)**Registration Process Activity**
--|indexAttributes|(% style="width:504px" %)(((
++|**Indexing Required**|**Registration Process Activity**
++|indexAttributes|(((
  **Data Set**
--Extract the content of the Attribute Values in a Data Set and create one or more Cube Regions containing Member Selections of Data Attribute Components of the Constraints model in the SDMXIM, and the associated Selection Value
++
++Extract the content of the Attribute Values in a Data Set and create one or more Cube Regions containing Member Selections of Data Attribute Components of the Constraints model in the
++
++SDMXIM, and the associated Selection Value
++
  **Metadata Set**
++
  Indicate the presence of a Reported Attribute by creating one or more Cube Regions containing Member Selections of Metadata Attribute Components of the Constraints model in the SDMX-IM. Note that the content is not stored in the Selection Value.
  )))
  )))
@@ -969,7 +969,7 @@
  The Registration must reference the ProvisionAgreement or MetadataProvisionAgreement to which it relates.
--=== {{id name="_Toc93876"/}}7.4.3 Registration Response ===
++===== {{id name="_Toc93876"/}}7.4.3 Registration Response =====
  After a registration request has been submitted to the registry, a response is returned to the submitter indicating success or failure. Given that a registration request can hold many Registrations, then there must be a registration status for each Registration. The SubmitRegistration class has a status field, which is either set to “Success”, “Warning” or “Failure”.
@@ -999,18 +999,20 @@
  Regardless of the type of registry/repository events being observed, a subscription always contains:
--1.  set of URIs describing the end-points to which notifications must be sent if the subscription is activated. The URIs can be either mailto~: or http: protocol. In the former case an email notification is sent; in the latter an HTTP POST notification is sent.
++1. A set of URIs describing the end-points to which notifications must be sent if the subscription is activated. The URIs can be either mailto~: or http: protocol. In the former case an email notification is sent; in the latter an HTTP POST notification is sent.
 . A user-defined identifier, which is returned in the response to the subscription request. This helps with asynchronous processing and is NOT stored in the Registry.
 . A validity period which defines both when the subscription becomes active and expires. The subscriber may be sent a notification on expiration of the subscription.
 . A selector which specifies which type of events are of interest. The set of event types is:
++:
++::
++
  (((
--(% style="width:856.294px" %)
--|(% style="width:320px" %)**Event Type**|(% style="width:532px" %)**Comment**
--|(% style="width:320px" %)STRUCTURAL_REPOSITORY_EVENTS|(% style="width:532px" %)Life-cycle changes to Maintainable Artefacts in the structural metadata repository.
--|(% style="width:320px" %)DATA_REGISTRATION_EVENTS|(% style="width:532px" %)Whenever a published dataset is registered. This can be either a SDMXML data file or an SDMX conformant database.
--|(% style="width:320px" %)METADATA_REGISTRATION_EVENTS|(% style="width:532px" %)Whenever a published metadataset is registered. This can be either a SDMXML reference metadata file or an SDMX conformant database.
--|(% style="width:320px" %)ALL_EVENTS|(% style="width:532px" %)All events of the specified EventType
++|**Event Type**|**Comment**
++|STRUCTURAL_REPOSITORY_EVENTS|Life-cycle changes to Maintainable Artefacts in the structural metadata repository.
++|DATA_REGISTRATION_EVENTS|Whenever a published dataset is registered. This can be either a SDMXML data file or an SDMX conformant database.
++|METADATA_REGISTRATION_EVENTS|Whenever a published metadataset is registered. This can be either a SDMXML reference metadata file or an SDMX conformant database.
++|ALL_EVENTS|All events of the specified EventType
  )))
  === {{id name="_Toc93880"/}}7.5.3 Wildcard Facility ===
@@ -1024,25 +1024,33 @@
  Examples of wildcarded identifier components for an identified object type of Codelist are shown below:
  AgencyID = *
++
  Id = *
++
  Version = *
  This subscribes to all Codelists of all versions for all agencies.
  AgencyID = AGENCY1
++
  Id = CODELIST1
++
  Version = *
  This subscribes to all versions of Codelist CODELIST1 maintained by the agency AGENCY1.
  AgencyID = AGENCY1
++
  Id = *
++
  Version = *
  This subscribes to all versions of all Codelist objects maintained by the agency AGENCY1.
  AgencyID = *
++
  Id = CODELIST1
++
  Version = *
  This subscribes to all versions of Codelist CODELIST1 maintained by any agency.
@@ -1069,14 +1069,15 @@
  Whenever a dataset or metadata-set is registered a registration event is created. A subscription may be observing all data or metadata registrations, or it may focus on specific registrations as shown in the table below:
++:
++
  (((
--(% style="width:1126.29px" %)
--|(% style="width:382px" %)**Selector**|(% style="width:740px" %)**Comment**
--|(% style="width:382px" %)DataProvider & MetadataProvider|(% style="width:740px" %)Any datasets or metadata sets registered by the specified data or metadata provider will activate the notification.
--|(% style="width:382px" %)ProvisionAgreement & MetadataProvisionAgreement|(% style="width:740px" %)Any datasets or metadata sets registered for the agreement will activate the notification.
--|(% style="width:382px" %)Dataflow & Metadataflow|(% style="width:740px" %)Any datasets or metadata sets registered for the specified dataflow (or metadataflow) will activate the notification.
--|(% style="width:382px" %)DataStructureDefinition & MetadataStructureDefinition|(% style="width:740px" %)Any datasets or metadata sets registered for those dataflows (or metadataflows) that are based on the specified Data Structure Definition will activate the notification
--|(% style="width:382px" %)Category|(% style="width:740px" %)Any datasets or metadata sets registered for those dataflows, metadataflows, provision agreements that are categorised by the category.
++|**Selector**|**Comment**
++|DataProvider & MetadataProvider|Any datasets or metadata sets registered by the specified data or metadata provider will activate the notification.
++|ProvisionAgreement & MetadataProvisionAgreement|Any datasets or metadata sets registered for the agreement will activate the notification.
++|Dataflow & Metadataflow|Any datasets or metadata sets registered for the specified dataflow (or metadataflow) will activate the notification.
++|DataStructureDefinition & MetadataStructureDefinition|Any datasets or metadata sets registered for those dataflows (or metadataflows) that are based on the specified Data Structure Definition will activate the notification
++|Category|Any datasets or metadata sets registered for those dataflows, metadataflows, provision agreements that are categorised by the category.
  )))
  The event will also capture the semantic of the registration: deletion or replacement of an existing registration or a new registration.
@@ -1108,6 +1108,12 @@
  The notification will contain the Registration.
------
++[[1>>path:#sdfootnote1anc||name="sdfootnote1sym"]] With semantic versioning, it is allowed to reference a range of artefacts, e.g., a DSD referencing a Codelist with version 1.2.3+ means all patch versions greater than 1.2.3. This means that deleting 1.2.4draft does not break integrity of the aforementioned DSD.
++[[2>>path:#sdfootnote2anc||name="sdfootnote2sym"]] The identification of an Agency in the URN structure for the maintainable object is by means of the agencyId. The AgencyScheme is not identified as SDMX has a mechanism for identifying an Agency uniquely by its Id. Note that this Id may be hierarchical. For example, a sub-agency of IMF is referred like this:
++
++IMF.SubAgency1
++
++[[3>>path:#sdfootnote3anc||name="sdfootnote3sym"]] Note that Codelist is also an EnumeratedList.
++
  {{putFootnotes/}}

SUZ.Methodology.Code.MethodologyClass[0]